Tolkien and The Long Defeat of the West.

Kieran

The GOAT
This was an interesting read for me this morning, that when JRR Tolkien wrote his epic myths of the Middle Earth, concluding with victory over Sauron in the Lord of the Rings, his intention wasn’t to create a tale of victory of Good over evil but instead, to describe what he called The Long Defeat. Hopefully you can open this short post from Instagram.

 
Last edited:
IMG_2737.png
 
I kind of feel the west is facing this Long defeat, due I’m to our “compassionate” intake of barbaric Islamist hordes who believe in child brides and beheading people on the streets. And due to our weak political systems which have encouraged traitors among us to undermine concepts such as truth and justice and freedom, with their deranged ideas and of course, perpetual “activism” which is little more than fifth columnist manoeuvres.

We are doomed to face a reckoning which we may not survive.
 
Last edited:
This is fascinating. I'm a huge Tolkien fan. The Hobbit, Lord of the Rings, Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales. I've read all of them, multiple times. If I ever had to pick a specialisation for Mastermind, I might very well pick the world that Tolkien created. But for all of that, I'm largely ignorant of what drove the man. I think you've inspired me to go and study!

I would take issue with your view that the Islamist hordes, and even immigration in the larger context is the problem. I think it's far more insidious than that. I think it's identity politics and the toxic empathy of this movement that's the poison in the body politic of the West. There's a hypothetical scenario where you get the same immigration but it's handled with a more pragmatic acceptance of multi-ethnic societies but a firm understanding that multiculturalism should be resisted. It blows my mind that those on the left have such a lack of common sense that they allow crazy break downs in society. This is what happens when weak men collude with the feminist ideology that seems to dominate the progressive movement. Biden allowing a huge inflow of immigrants was beyond stupid. I might not be the biggest fan of Obama but my goodness that man knew how to faithfully adhere to the law of the land where immigration was concerned. Unfortunately he did other things that made Trump possible, and he IS responsible for Trump. He pushed for Hillary to be the candidate, imagine if Biden had been allowed to take on Trump, none of this would have happened, and I bet you Biden would have won easily. But that wasn't even the worst thing Obama did. Protecting the banks and hedge funds lost the Democrats the industrial heartland, because voters realised that Democrats weren't for the little people anymore. They were willing to provide safe haven for bankers, but didn't give a damn about industries that were decimated by globalisation.

But.. going back to Tolkien.. I find it fascinating that even in a time that we now look back on, the time of post war reconstruction, of high economic growth, full employment. There was a pessimism about the future. I guess we're not quite as unique as we think we are, perhaps that's the deeper lesson in this? There's always a journey, there's always great work that needs to be done to secure a better future
 
This is fascinating. I'm a huge Tolkien fan. The Hobbit, Lord of the Rings, Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales. I've read all of them, multiple times. If I ever had to pick a specialisation for Mastermind, I might very well pick the world that Tolkien created. But for all of that, I'm largely ignorant of what drove the man. I think you've inspired me to go and study!

I would take issue with your view that the Islamist hordes, and even immigration in the larger context is the problem. I think it's far more insidious than that. I think it's identity politics and the toxic empathy of this movement that's the poison in the body politic of the West. There's a hypothetical scenario where you get the same immigration but it's handled with a more pragmatic acceptance of multi-ethnic societies but a firm understanding that multiculturalism should be resisted. It blows my mind that those on the left have such a lack of common sense that they allow crazy break downs in society. This is what happens when weak men collude with the feminist ideology that seems to dominate the progressive movement. Biden allowing a huge inflow of immigrants was beyond stupid. I might not be the biggest fan of Obama but my goodness that man knew how to faithfully adhere to the law of the land where immigration was concerned. Unfortunately he did other things that made Trump possible, and he IS responsible for Trump. He pushed for Hillary to be the candidate, imagine if Biden had been allowed to take on Trump, none of this would have happened, and I bet you Biden would have won easily. But that wasn't even the worst thing Obama did. Protecting the banks and hedge funds lost the Democrats the industrial heartland, because voters realised that Democrats weren't for the little people anymore. They were willing to provide safe haven for bankers, but didn't give a damn about industries that were decimated by globalisation.

But.. going back to Tolkien.. I find it fascinating that even in a time that we now look back on, the time of post war reconstruction, of high economic growth, full employment. There was a pessimism about the future. I guess we're not quite as unique as we think we are, perhaps that's the deeper lesson in this? There's always a journey, there's always great work that needs to be done to secure a better future
Yeah I read LOTR when I was eighteen and it staggered me. Everything about it, the characters, all the different stages of journey, bombadil, Strider in the pub in Bree,Glorfindel racing up the river to help Frodo, it was epic in every page. I loved the epilogues which told more about Aragorn after the war. Their I’ll fated Trek with Gandalf, “Fly you fools!” I always thought he was a bit unkind here :lol6:, I hadn’t hated anyone yet at that age except McEnroe in 1980 the way I hated Gollum and his tricksy moooching, just everything about it. Boromir’s death. It’s a staggering achievement. I read other related books too but can’t remember which, where I am now. So much wisdom too. Gandalf The wizard sounds like a wizard should, wise and kind. I’m tempted to dig out it out when I get home!

The concept of the long defeat is a very relatable one. We’re facing the two worst ideologies to afflict hummankind, communism and Islamism, both of which are really about violent subjugation and tyranny. Catastrophes for whoever they conquer. Perhaps we’ll make it, but I too am now curious about his thinking…
 
Last edited:
Yeah I read LOTR when I was eighteen and it staggered me. Everything about it, the characters, all the different stages of journey, bombadil, Strider in the pub in Bree,Glorfindel racing up the river to help Frodo, it was epic in every page. I loved the epilogues which told more about Aragorn after the war. Their I’ll fated Trek with Gandalf, “Fly you fools!” I always thought he was a bit unkind here :lol6:, I hadn’t hated anyone yet at that age except McEnroe in 1980 the way I hated Gollum and his tricksy moooching, just everything about it. Boromir’s death. It’s a staggering achievement. I read other related books too but can’t remember which, where I am now. So much wisdom too. Gandalf The wizard sounds like a wizard should, wise and kind. I’m tempted to dig out it out when I get home!

The concept of the long defeat is a very relatable one. We’re facing the two worst ideologies to afflict hummankind, communism and Islamism, both of which are really about violent subjugation and tyranny. Catastrophes for whoever they conquer. Perhaps we’ll make it, but I too am now curious about his thinking…
Declining chronic birth rates for the Western nations and even the Asian super powers is going to decimate our societies and the capitalistic model.

Where are the consumers 20 years from now to make these nations grow & expand?

One example: France cannot sustain its social services & service its overwhelming debt and at the same time immigration is changing French social fabric.

The loss of native population is a cunundrum…
 
Declining chronic birth rates for the Western nations and even the Asian super powers is going to decimate our societies and the capitalistic model.

Where are the consumers 20 years from now to make these nations grow & expand?

One example: France cannot sustain its social services & service its overwhelming debt and at the same time immigration is changing French social fabric.

The loss of native population is a cunundrum…
Great point. This equates with a loss of native culture. Mass immigration from certain places where the culture is totally incompatible with the West is like injecting ourselves with poison. The solution is to insist that if there are genuine refugees from Muslim countries that other Muslim countries such as Qatar and Saudi Arabia get ready to take them in, but they won’t. I think it suits some ME countries that the West is so “compassionate”. That might still be a problem for a Muslim country that takes them in, but we have to staunch the flow.
 
Great point. This equates with a loss of native culture. Mass immigration from certain places where the culture is totally incompatible with the West is like injecting ourselves with poison. The solution is to insist that if there are genuine refugees from Muslim countries that other Muslim countries such as Qatar and Saudi Arabia get ready to take them in, but they won’t. I think it suits some ME countries that the West is so “compassionate”. That might still be a problem for a Muslim country that takes them in, but we have to staunch the flow.
But it still begs the existential question, how do you replace an aging & not self sustaining population? That is the greatest threat to free market capitalism

Love it or hate, the US can absorb immigrants (for various factors) easier than other Western Countries. Hispanics in Texans consider themselves Texans first, Americans second & Hispanics third…..LOL
 
But it still begs the existential question, how do you replace an aging & not self sustaining population? That is the greatest threat to free market capitalism

Love it or hate, the US can absorb immigrants (for various factors) easier than other Western Countries. Hispanics in Texans consider themselves Texans first, Americans second & Hispanics third…..LOL
That’s compatible immigration and that’s good. There are ideologies incompatible with free societies and actually opposed to our freedoms that we seem not to have much of policy on when it comes to limiting their entry into Europe
 
Declining chronic birth rates for the Western nations and even the Asian super powers is going to decimate our societies and the capitalistic model.

Where are the consumers 20 years from now to make these nations grow & expand?

One example: France cannot sustain its social services & service its overwhelming debt and at the same time immigration is changing French social fabric.

The loss of native population is a cunundrum…

The model itself is unsustainable and therefore a bigger problem in it self. All Western countries are trillions in debt. The source of the problem is not Islamists.
 
Islam is like the ghoul of death hovering over the West. Remember when there used to talk about the clash of civilisations? But this was always a misnomer because for civilisations to clash there needs to be more than one civilisation involved and Islam is not a civilisation and never brought civilisation anywhere. It’s a nihilistic, barbaric anibalistic death cult and we need to resist it many ways. ; unfortunately we’ve lost our faith in the west both spiritually and faith in our western freedoms and ideals. And this is the cause of our demise. We’ll be devoured by the descendants of a murderous PDF file warlord. Yeats was right, the best lack all conviction while the worst are filled with murderous intensity. All the very worst ideas are becoming seductive to many in the West…
 
Islam is like the ghoul of death hovering over the West. Remember when there used to talk about the clash of civilisations? But this was always a misnomer because for civilisations to clash there needs to be more than one civilisation involved and Islam is not a civilisation and never brought civilisation anywhere. It’s a nihilistic, barbaric anibalistic death cult and we need to resist it many ways. ; unfortunately we’ve lost our faith in the west both spiritually and faith in our western freedoms and ideals. And this is the cause of our demise. We’ll be devoured by the descendants of a murderous PDF file warlord. Yeats was right, the best lack all conviction while the worst are filled with murderous intensity. All the very worst ideas are becoming seductive to many in the West…
You're focusing on the stone that came through your window rather than the person who threw it.

The people you talk of are not "invading the west" in a conventional sense - they're being directed in. It's not as if there isn't a pattern - US, Canada, Australia, NZ, Portugal, Italy, France, Scandinavia... Ireland probably being the worst per head of population. Don't you think this could be stopped by Armed Forces and Intelligence agencies if there was a will to do it? Of course, but you're more likely to become their target if you complain about it too loudly.
 
No I’m focusing on both. Less Islam isn’t a goal or an avoidance of the issue, it’s basic survival and an immediate practically. The cause is lack of faith and loss of confidence and identity in the west, which encourages the worst people and ideas to come here and then rewards them…
 
Last edited:
No I’m focusing on both. Less Islam isn’t a goal or an avoidance of the issue, it’s basic survival and an immediate practically. The cause is lack of faith and loss of confidence and identity in the west, which encourages the worst people and ideas to come here and then rewards them…
I disagree entirely mate. It's not driven bottom up, it's driven top-down. The confidence and identity of the west has been eroded by design - it's not organic. The west as you know it has been purposely taken apart from within.
 
Back
Top