Moxie
Multiple Major Winner
Random. Also, I think you missed my point of the anecdote.The relevance was related to your mention of "natural allies". It seems that isn't a shoo-in, and can't be taken for granted.
Random. Also, I think you missed my point of the anecdote.The relevance was related to your mention of "natural allies". It seems that isn't a shoo-in, and can't be taken for granted.
lol! Imagine the amount of work they would have to do on his show! Better yet imagine the same for a show like 'Love thy Neighbour'?They even edit Only Fools and Horses on BBC re-runs, so Alfie boy doesn't have a chance.

If you felt the need to tell your friend, that's one thing, but isn't what pronoun you use a different question?Not if they were born with a penis.
Imagine a scenario where I introduced this trans-person to a male friend of mine, and they were under the impression that they were interacting with a woman? And this trans-person didn't feel the need to let my friend know that they were originally a man. That would be a horrific betrayal of the bro-code as far as I'm concerned.
well I apply a common sense standard to the scenario. If I told my friend that I was introducing him to a woman and he punches me in the face later because he feels I lied to him then that's a problemIf you felt the need to tell your friend, that's one thing, but isn't what pronoun you use a different question?
OK, grampa. I'll go ahead and get off your lawn now.well I apply a common sense standard to the scenario. If I told my friend that I was introducing him to a woman and he punches me in the face later because he feels I lied to him then that's a problem
lol! Not sure where the "grampa" comes from. A heterosexual guy is going to expect his mate introducing him to someone that presents as a woman to warn him if that's not the case. That's just the way it is. I don't see that as old fashioned. That's just being straight forward.OK, grampa. I'll go ahead and get off your lawn now.
lol! Not sure where the "grampa" comes from. A heterosexual guy is going to expect his mate introducing him to someone that presents as a woman to warn him if that's not the case. That's just the way it is. I don't see that as old fashioned. That's just being straight forward.
@britbox actually raises another issue that's been topical recently. He mentioned it in the context of Martina Navratilova's comments. But let me be more specific. There have been cases of men who have transitioned to women who have fought in MMA. Not surprisingly they've destroyed real women. That should never have been allowed to happen
by the way, there was also a case of a trans-person. Specifically a dude who still had his business but had breasts (presumably from hormone treatment) who when sentenced to prison elected to be put in a female prison. He ended up raping women in prison. I think this is the link...
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news...ho-sexually-assaulted-inmates-jailed-for-life
now you've completely lost me hereI think you misunderstood my post. I said I could see telling your friend, but asked you if you'd use feminine pronouns for a trans woman? You're the one that started the conversation about pronouns & PC.
whoa there... please don't include someone like Caster Semenya in this discussion. I think elective gender alterations are a completely different thing. I've also noticed you trying to set definitions... not sure what a trans woman is, I'll respectfully just stick with trans person, it's less confusing. But actually to your point about if it's a pc issue, it clearly is. It seems that a reluctance to acknowledge that a man who has transitioned to a woman still retains a mans strength has caused major problems. Sometimes this identity labelling actually ends up eliminating frank debate. This person who has transitioned still retains the characteristics of their original gender no matter how much they have tried to eliminate it. We have to be honest about it. Failure to do so because of some PC requirement leads to real women getting stomped in sports, the potential for sexual violence etc. The fact that a trans person is more likely to be harmed should not invalidate our responsibility to not give every trans person privileges with the other sex that wasn't their prerogative prior to surgery. Just my view... Caitlyn Jenner shouldn't suddenly be able to walk into a woman's changing room is what I'm saying... If I'm a neanderthal or grampa in your view, I'm ok with thatAs to britbox's point, it was about divisiveness in the LGBT+ community. The issue of trans women and women with high T counts in sports is very different, and not really a question of PC, but a larger issue, wouldn't you say? Though I'm willing to discuss.
whoa there... please don't include someone like Caster Semenya in this discussion. I think elective gender alterations are a completely different thing. I've also noticed you trying to set definitions... not sure what a trans woman is, I'll respectfully just stick with trans person, it's less confusing. But actually to your point about if it's a pc issue, it clearly is. It seems that a reluctance to acknowledge that a man who has transitioned to a woman still retains a mans strength has caused major problems. Sometimes this identity labelling actually ends up eliminating frank debate. This person who has transitioned still retains the characteristics of their original gender no matter how much they have tried to eliminate it. We have to be honest about it. Failure to do so because of some PC requirement leads to real women getting stomped in sports, the potential for sexual violence etc. The fact that a trans person is more likely to be harmed should not invalidate our responsibility to not give every trans person privileges with the other sex that wasn't their prerogative prior to surgery. Just my view... Caitlyn Jenner shouldn't suddenly be able to walk into a woman's changing room is what I'm saying... If I'm a neanderthal or grampa in your view, I'm ok with that![]()
so you say, yet I haven't heard it before. But in any case I certainly like being comfortable with what I sayI used a term that is common. It's you who's trying to set a definition here...with "trans person." You use words that make you comfortable, as you like.
Watch the video, you'll hear it.so you say, yet I haven't heard it before. But in any case I certainly like being comfortable with what I say![]()
I'm trying to figure out what you're going for here, @Murat Baslamisli. Yes, if you're a supremacist, that really does imply "white." What other options are you looking at? Black supremacy? First Nations/native American supremacy? In what world? So I think we can agree that there is a historical prescident for the notion of white supremacy, and not really for any other kind. And that it has been used specifically to undermine people of color and immigrants. You agree with that?The problem is , when the right goes too far, it is usually easy to pinpoint and single out. Like, you are a supremacist for a certain race (usually white) , you are homophobic, you are a Nazi etc...It is easy. The problem with the left is, when they go too far, they sneak it past the society in such subtle ways that before you know it, you are a "grandpa". Like, right now, if I do not want to date a trans woman, I am a bigot. If I say I would rather have my woman without a penis, I am not invited to San Francisco. The far left has gone insane . Just like the far right, they have become slaves to an ideology that they believe actually benefits the society. And of course they will wail on the streets like the morons that they are after Trump gets elected again and blame the racist bigoted homophobic transphobic white men without once looking at the mirror. Of course the sad part is a colossal prick like Trump will get elected once more. And of course the far left will not even entertain the idea that they themselves are the reason for it. End result ? Center left and center right gets screwed once again. Exact same thing happening in Canada too by the way. The middle is afraid to even talk because they get buried by their own side...Sad times.
There are other supremacists than white. A quick google search can help you there. But of course we all use the term generally to mean white and it is the correct way. Not a problem there.I'm trying to figure out what you're going for here, @Murat Baslamisli. Yes, if you're a supremacist, that really does imply "white." What other options are you looking at? Black supremacy? First Nations/native American supremacy? In what world? So I think we can agree that there is a historical prescident for the notion of white supremacy, and not really for any other kind. And that it has been used specifically to undermine people of color and immigrants. You agree with that?
As to the rest, some of it really does go off the rails: does anyone say you're a bigot if you don't want to date a trans woman? Does anyone exclude you from going to SF for not dating trans people? You really take that too far. I mean, seriously.
So then on top of it, you blame us, the Dems/left for Trump, or your left in Canada. I think this is unfair, and rather outrageous. Trump speaks in specific racist language, polarizes people in my country, and you're trying to put some of this on the voice coming from the left? In what way, really? I understand that there are a lot of people in the middle who feel they are not heard, but they have choices. One is not to pull in with the racists. Another is not to buy into the cult of personality of Trump and his autocratic ways. The Dems at least offer an alternative, and that's why they made big strides in the most recent election here in the US. I think the middle controls the elections, and it is up to them to decide if they're swayed by dog-whistling to their worst instincts, or if they're willing to vote for their own best interests. Laying back and pretending victimhood is childish, and, thb, what got us here, at least in the US. No one is forcing you to date trans people. No one is forcing you to vote for conservatives, or liberals. You have options in this world. Take ownership of your own political views. IMO, those who act like they have no voice are not using it.