Chess

the inter web is up in arms about it :D To be honest, I my guess is that the judgement against him is a bit harsh, even though I do think he doesn't help himself (I do secretly admire the fact he really doesn't seem to give a fuck). What I mean about the judgement being harsh is that what he did - this time - was within the rules (so it's been said on X). He even checked with the arbiters before he did it first right? So it seems like his crime was acting against the spirit of the competition not the rules like in jeans-gate? I'm actually not expressing an opinion here (I haven't watched), I'm asking
it definitely is not breaking any rules. The main thing to note is that you can forfeit the game and it does not affect rating points.

In Magnus’s match against the lovely Bibisara, he did beat her bad enough the first day that he won the first set even after he forfeited the classical game. And in the 2nd day against Bibi, he beat her bad enough that the forfeit led to the 2nd set being tied, so Magnus won that match. Do I think it’s crappy what he did…absolutely! And it’s obviously convenient as well.

But then the last two days are way worse and even a bit bizarre. Yesterday, he had the lead after the blitz portion, then decided to forfeit the rapid games leaving him behind, and then he won the classical game as white. Today, Magnus played the blitz and rapid games, was slightly behind, and then forfeited the classical game as black. Since the match was then tied, it went to an Armageddon blitz game which Magnus won.

So yeah, he didn’t break rules but clearly he was more or less being a pussy and wasn’t letting his opponents know he wasn’t going to play them. I do wonder what Magnus’s plan was in regards to forfeiting rapids yesterday. I imagine if he drew classical game yesterday and lost that first set, he wouldn’t have played at all today, but that’s conjecture. Either way, I am hoping Sindarov passes him up quick. Not sure Caruana is the man for the job IMO.
 
it definitely is not breaking any rules. The main thing to note is that you can forfeit the game and it does not affect rating points.

In Magnus’s match against the lovely Bibisara, he did beat her bad enough the first day that he won the first set even after he forfeited the classical game. And in the 2nd day against Bibi, he beat her bad enough that the forfeit led to the 2nd set being tied, so Magnus won that match. Do I think it’s crappy what he did…absolutely! And it’s obviously convenient as well.

But then the last two days are way worse and even a bit bizarre. Yesterday, he had the lead after the blitz portion, then decided to forfeit the rapid games leaving him behind, and then he won the classical game as white. Today, Magnus played the blitz and rapid games, was slightly behind, and then forfeited the classical game as black. Since the match was then tied, it went to an Armageddon blitz game which Magnus won.

So yeah, he didn’t break rules but clearly he was more or less being a pussy and wasn’t letting his opponents know he wasn’t going to play them. I do wonder what Magnus’s plan was in regards to forfeiting rapids yesterday. I imagine if he drew classical game yesterday and lost that first set, he wouldn’t have played at all today, but that’s conjecture. Either way, I am hoping Sindarov passes him up quick. Not sure Caruana is the man for the job IMO.
so basically he was protecting his 2800 status, and I suppose his number 1 ranking. That is pussy behaviour. I think pretty much everyone believes that if he puts the effort in he's still the best player in the world. But if fatherhood and family life prevents him from putting in the work then he needs to get up outta there. When Magnus manages to put Emil Sutovsky on the side of the light you know things have got really bad. I've seen some social media clips of Hikaru, Fabiano and yesterday tweets from MVL which have been savage. What on earth is he thinking?? He should hunker down, sign up for Wijk aan Zee and kick everyone's ass. Show who he is. If he doesn't want to do that then step back and don't disgrace his legacy
 
Interesting

Interesting you say this, Iwatched this video earlier and wondered what you and @Federberg Might make of it. Magnus seems to be trending away from wanting to make a Great Comeback as the world champ: Fischer might have been spot on.


This is very interesting and is exactly what this fast classical is trying to address. I do think Carlsen is dealing with more than just a burnout for classical chess, and his play and antics at this past tournament show it. There is probably a loss of motivation overall and that and age will continue to affect his play. Magnus does have a strong, nasty, beautiful wife and a baby now. Let’s just say he better not screw that up or you do wonder where his mental state will go.

I will say though that the format in the knockout stage was dumb…just way too much chess before you even play the fast classical, and I think that led to a lot of quick draws. When it was just the 2 fast classical games the first 5 days it seemed that there were more decisive games. I think that was what Wesley So was mainly upset about; 4 blitz games and 2 rapids before the fast classical is dumb.
 
This is very interesting and is exactly what this fast classical is trying to address. I do think Carlsen is dealing with more than just a burnout for classical chess, and his play and antics at this past tournament show it. There is probably a loss of motivation overall and that and age will continue to affect his play. Magnus does have a strong, nasty, beautiful wife and a baby now. Let’s just say he better not screw that up or you do wonder where his mental state will go.

I will say though that the format in the knockout stage was dumb…just way too much chess before you even play the fast classical, and I think that led to a lot of quick draws. When it was just the 2 fast classical games the first 5 days it seemed that there were more decisive games. I think that was what Wesley So was mainly upset about; 4 blitz games and 2 rapids before the fast classical is dumb.
lol! Is his wife nasty? In what way?
 
lol! Is his wife nasty? In what way?
She had this epic death stare when Bibisara asked Magnus for a selfie. There was another video after a tournament where they were walking and she was clearly pissed. And overall…she just has that look, lol

 
Last edited:


This interview with Carlsen after the event says it all. Quite honest about everything really.

I agree with him he definitely is in a different place. And to be fair to him, I think it's understandable that he might want to protect his rating more fiercely than others, he's in the number one spot after all. And it's one thing to lose your rating in a more normal classical time control. But even the most rabid Magnus hater has to admit that if he's going to lose his number one ranking or - to my mind - his 2800 status, doing it due to this time control is a bit sketchy
 
This is balanced


I think parts of that are and parts aren’t. I like the part where the guy at the end says this is not defending Magnus because he’s Magnus :) We can choose to believe what we want there haha.

One excellent point he has is that I agree this should not have counted towards the classical rating. However, none of them had a gun to their head forcing them to play, so there is that.

The forfeits against Bibisara are at least somewhat understandable, but to say he had nothing to gain is inaccurate. If this was your normal, confident Magnus one would expect him to easily roll her in both classical games and gain close to 6 points. With her rating being much lower, a draw in the first game would have taken him below 2800, and 2 draws would have put him at serious risk of not being #1.

And then he quickly glossed over the forfeits vs Artemiev which are pretty damning since he hadn’t clinched that match.
 
I think parts of that are and parts aren’t. I like the part where the guy at the end says this is not defending Magnus because he’s Magnus :) We can choose to believe what we want there haha.

One excellent point he has is that I agree this should not have counted towards the classical rating. However, none of them had a gun to their head forcing them to play, so there is that.

The forfeits against Bibisara are at least somewhat understandable, but to say he had nothing to gain is inaccurate. If this was your normal, confident Magnus one would expect him to easily roll her in both classical games and gain close to 6 points. With her rating being much lower, a draw in the first game would have taken him below 2800, and 2 draws would have put him at serious risk of not being #1.

And then he quickly glossed over the forfeits vs Artemiev which are pretty damning since he hadn’t clinched that match.
I think such a radically different time control should have been tested first before going towards rating. That doesn't excuse Magnus of course

I think FIDE officials, particularly Sutovsky going against Magnus personally was tacky at the very least, considering their format and lack of clear rules opened the door to the issues shows that it's in their interest to degrade his standing to elevate the World Championship. I dislike being used so I'm instinctively going to push back on that narrative.

It's all a sad mess, and I actually have a lot of sympathy for Magnus because he's absolutely correct, he HAD to participate given what he had said in the past, even if he might not have been feeling it at this particular moment in time. Still he could have handled things with more respect towards his opponents. That's really the part where there's simply no excuse for his behaviour
 
Back
Top