Chess

DarthFed

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
18,145
Reactions
3,736
Points
113
I honestly don't believe that Gukesh has or ever will be able to separate himself from his peers... Pragg, Nordibek, Erigaisi, Keymer, or Sindarov etc. I still think in match play he would probably fall short of certainly Fabi, probably Hikaru as well. He's a super strong player at his best of course, but will history consider him any different from a Topalov or even Ponomariov? I'm not so sure. This is why I think Kasparov has been quite dismissive.

PS, I actually think Firouzja is most likely in the same tier as Fabi and Hikaru in a match play situation. I think his problem is maintaining the concentration to actually get there, but once there I still think Magnus is right, the talent is strong in that one
Yes, this definitely seems to be the case with Gukesh in regards to the competition, especially since he has fallen off significantly since winning WC. I think he’d be an underdog against everyone you mentioned right now as well as the OG’s.

With that said Gukesh has played well at the Olympiad, but that’s on 4th board (!!) for India. I know India has many strong players but for the WC to be 4th board is crazy! But still, he will take any little momentum he can get against Sindarov who has kept having strong results after dominating the Candidates tournament.

Firouzja is an interesting one too. I will say that there is a decent chance that those that are still very bullish on him in classical (like Magnus and Hikaru) may be heavily influenced on his skills in speed chess. Alireza has stalled out in classical and has been especially bad in the Candidates. And part of that of course could be his interest in fashion. He is called Guccireza for a reason :)
that puts Kasparov's dominance into perspective. Feels like Magnus has been ruling the roost forever, but he still has another 6 years to catch up. That's mad! I will say this though... I think Magnus's length of dominance is actually more impressive that Garry's because Kasparov had an edge with his opening prep that was massive. Yes of course other players could have tried to build up their own opening prep work, but the barrier to entry for that at that time was much more difficult. Magnus has largely maintained his lead by simply being a better chess player than everyone else (that's not to say Garry wasn't). We live in an era where computers have given everyone an equal capability with regards to preparation, so now it truly is completely about ability. It's not clear to me that Garry was that much superior to Karpov, Vishy and Kramnik if you controlled for his opening advantage.
I definitely wouldn’t view Magnus’s run in classical as being more dominant than Garry, especially when we factor in that Carlsen has been a part-time player in classical chess for many years already. With that said, what you said is definitely correct that chess is more difficult to dominate now. But that has always been true over time and will continue to be the case in the future as generations build off each other and openings become more and more played out, leading to a higher % of draws. Also, just the spike in the popularity of chess figures to lead to a more competitive field compared to now, let alone 30 years ago,

I also don’t think we can just dismiss Kasparov’s ability in openings as being more or less something handed to him. There definitely is talent involved, and what it came down to is that Garry was a master in playing to his strengths and so often got what he wanted out of the opening; a dynamic position where once he grabbed the initiative it was basically game over.

Regarding the players you mentioned, Garry dog walks them in brute calculation and tactical skills and he also was very difficult to beat even when his attacks fizzled. For the couple players that Garry struggled against (Karpov and Kramnik) styles make fights. Karpov was so strong positionally and was dynamic, maybe too much for his own good when it came to playing Garry. Kramnik was more a pure positional player in his prime and wisely took all the air out of the positions against Kasparov. He also seems to have sold his soul to the devil; on top of being a piece of shit, the chess he played leading up to and during that match is something he never duplicated after. Anyways, if you take Garry’s opening play away, you could say the same about Carlsen with endgames and wonder how his results would be if he wasn’t so superior there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Federberg

DarthFed

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
18,145
Reactions
3,736
Points
113
Was able to beat Nigel Short again in a wild game. He must be on a cold streak as he’s usually around 3000 on there. Was a mate in 1 before he ran out of time, but I had also missed a mate in 3 a few moves before.
IMG_0693.png
 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: Federberg

Federberg

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
17,839
Reactions
7,264
Points
113
this gives you an idea of what black has to deal with once the his queen gets greedy and takes that pawn..

 

Kieran

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
18,706
Reactions
8,604
Points
113
This Ivanchuk dude must be either single or very brave to post this :lol6:
 

Federberg

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
17,839
Reactions
7,264
Points
113
looks like we're about to see something we haven't seen in more than a decade and a half. Magnus might be a sub-2800 player the next time he plays classical. And even before that Fabi might pass him on the live rating.

1794773178652.jpeg
 
Last edited:

DarthFed

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
18,145
Reactions
3,736
Points
113
looks like we're about to see something we haven't seen in more than a decade and a half. Magnus might be a sub-2800 player the next time he plays classical. And even before that Fabi might pass him on the live rating.

View attachment 11123
I like the idea of fast classical as it will promote the game better than games that can last 5 or 6 hours. However, a 45/30 format is really like a slow rapid game. Change the fast classical to like 75/30 and I think it’s good. Trust me, even 75/30 would be a way different ballgame than the current control of 90 minutes for first 40 moves and then an extra 30 minutes, all with 30 second increment.

I was surprised Carlsen performed so badly here as I figure this 45/30 would be a great time control for him. And maybe it will still end up being so since this is the first time it’s been played. This time control should also appeal to him since he can play 10 classical games over 5 or 6 days compared to something like 10 games over 12 days or 12 games over 15 days. On the flip side I am not sure this is going to end up being a strong time control for Caruana even though he’s had a strong result so far.

We will see if Magnus can hold onto #1. If playing this bad in classical lately (last 2 tournaments have been a disaster) and losing #1 doesn’t motivate him in classical, then nothing will.

I’m still not sure Fabi will be that guy unless Carlsen plays more and continues to plummet. I just don’t think Fabi has that clutch gene. He likely did feel pressure coming into today since he was so close to #1 and he blew a winning position in game 1 and then got rolled in game 2 against the much lower rated Artemiev.

Magnus’s clock management has been terrible the last two tournaments and probably contributed heavily to him not converting in the first game against Nepo today. Age is a factor of course since Magnus is about to be 36 and has been on top for so long, but if he isn’t fully motivated that is probably a bigger factor.
 

Federberg

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
17,839
Reactions
7,264
Points
113
I like the idea of fast classical as it will promote the game better than games that can last 5 or 6 hours. However, a 45/30 format is really like a slow rapid game. Change the fast classical to like 75/30 and I think it’s good. Trust me, even 75/30 would be a way different ballgame than the current control of 90 minutes for first 40 moves and then an extra 30 minutes, all with 30 second increment.

I was surprised Carlsen performed so badly here as I figure this 45/30 would be a great time control for him. And maybe it will still end up being so since this is the first time it’s been played. This time control should also appeal to him since he can play 10 classical games over 5 or 6 days compared to something like 10 games over 12 days or 12 games over 15 days. On the flip side I am not sure this is going to end up being a strong time control for Caruana even though he’s had a strong result so far.

We will see if Magnus can hold onto #1. If playing this bad in classical lately (last 2 tournaments have been a disaster) and losing #1 doesn’t motivate him in classical, then nothing will.

I’m still not sure Fabi will be that guy unless Carlsen plays more and continues to plummet. I just don’t think Fabi has that clutch gene. He likely did feel pressure coming into today since he was so close to #1 and he blew a winning position in game 1 and then got rolled in game 2 against the much lower rated Artemiev.

Magnus’s clock management has been terrible the last two tournaments and probably contributed heavily to him not converting in the first game against Nepo today. Age is a factor of course since Magnus is about to be 36 and has been on top for so long, but if he isn’t fully motivated that is probably a bigger factor.
I haven't watched any of the games, but I do wonder if some of the lethargy that seemed to plague Vishy is finally catching up to him. This whole thing is giving me Federer mid-30s vibes. Time waits for no one!
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarthFed

DarthFed

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
18,145
Reactions
3,736
Points
113
I haven't watched any of the games, but I do wonder if some of the lethargy that seemed to plague Vishy is finally catching up to him. This whole thing is giving me Federer mid-30s vibes. Time waits for no one!
Age in chess is a weird thing as far as when players are past their best, and I think it’s always been different player to player and style is a factor as well. I feel like the strong positional players should age better than attacking players who require deeper calculation. But regardless of style, mental fatigue and lack of ability to stay focused is going to creep up more as players age and I think Magnus may be experiencing that in classical. He used to move very quickly and would enjoy a big time advantage on nearly all his opponents in classical, and now it’s the opposite.

Carlsen has been at or near the top for close to 20 years already, doesn’t enjoy classical, and feels unmotivated there even when it comes to being world champion. In previous eras it was all about classical as there were very few important blitz or rapid events and online chess didn’t exist. So Carlsen’s struggles are understandable and it’s possible he won’t really be able to turn the tide. I doubt he continues to free fall, but even if he gets motivated and plays a lot more classical, it will be tough for him to get back to near peak levels when he was consistently 2850+

It’s going to be very interesting to see how the new generation ages. Guys like Carlsen, Naka and Caruana, all born around 1990, definitely played a good amount online and trained with computers growing up, but not to the extent of players these days. I do think the players these days will hit their peak a lot earlier and will also be past their best at an earlier age too, but that is to be determined.

We can see signs of it already with a player like Alireza. He hit his peak rating of 2804 five years ago already at age 18, upon which he was crowned the heir apparent to Carlsen, and it seemed to be a given. Since then he’s had inconsistent results, including a couple poor candidate tournaments, has lost about 50 points, and has been passed up by guys younger than him. Alireza is still only 23, so of course the best may still be yet to come. But in prior eras you never saw a budding 18 year old star seemingly regress at all, let alone significantly. But then again you never saw an 18 year old get to 2800. I do think we will see more and more of this though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Federberg

Federberg

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
17,839
Reactions
7,264
Points
113
Age in chess is a weird thing as far as when players are past their best, and I think it’s always been different player to player and style is a factor as well. I feel like the strong positional players should age better than attacking players who require deeper calculation. But regardless of style, mental fatigue and lack of ability to stay focused is going to creep up more as players age and I think Magnus may be experiencing that in classical. He used to move very quickly and would enjoy a big time advantage on nearly all his opponents in classical, and now it’s the opposite.

Carlsen has been at or near the top for close to 20 years already, doesn’t enjoy classical, and feels unmotivated there even when it comes to being world champion. In previous eras it was all about classical as there were very few important blitz or rapid events and online chess didn’t exist. So Carlsen’s struggles are understandable and it’s possible he won’t really be able to turn the tide. I doubt he continues to free fall, but even if he gets motivated and plays a lot more classical, it will be tough for him to get back to near peak levels when he was consistently 2850+

It’s going to be very interesting to see how the new generation ages. Guys like Carlsen, Naka and Caruana, all born around 1990, definitely played a good amount online and trained with computers growing up, but not to the extent of players these days. I do think the players these days will hit their peak a lot earlier and will also be past their best at an earlier age too, but that is to be determined.

We can see signs of it already with a player like Alireza. He hit his peak rating of 2804 five years ago already at age 18, upon which he was crowned the heir apparent to Carlsen, and it seemed to be a given. Since then he’s had inconsistent results, including a couple poor candidate tournaments, has lost about 50 points, and has been passed up by guys younger than him. Alireza is still only 23, so of course the best may still be yet to come. But in prior eras you never saw a budding 18 year old star seemingly regress at all, let alone significantly. But then again you never saw an 18 year old get to 2800. I do think we will see more and more of this though.
that's a very good point about players peaking earlier and possibly not being able to sustain it for as long.

From what I hear the time controls were also a factor in this. I recall a Norway Chess a few years back that had whacky time controls where Magnus didn't fare well. Wesley So was seriously put out by the time controls and tweeted about it. He's not a prolific tweeter, so for him to do that says something
 

DarthFed

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
18,145
Reactions
3,736
Points
113
Kasparov joked that he could come back now that Carlsen fell below the rating he was when he retired (2813). Even as a joke, if that doesn’t expose how dumb the current system is, nothing will. I do think at a minimum they should penalize any top 100-200 players who do not play a certain amount of classical games each year. Maybe something where they have to play at least 20 classical games each year or they lose up to 50 points, so 2.5 points lost for every game they are short of that 20-game minimum.

Now if a top player retires I could see it being a bit different. Maybe they change it to 20 points per year until they fall out of the top 100 or wherever you cut it off. But this would prevent craziness like what Kasparov is joking about, or even the current situation where Topalov and Anand are way overrated because they barely play but could still get invites based on their ranking.
 

Federberg

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
17,839
Reactions
7,264
Points
113
Kasparov joked that he could come back now that Carlsen fell below the rating he was when he retired (2813). Even as a joke, if that doesn’t expose how dumb the current system is, nothing will. I do think at a minimum they should penalize any top 100-200 players who do not play a certain amount of classical games each year. Maybe something where they have to play at least 20 classical games each year or they lose up to 50 points, so 2.5 points lost for every game they are short of that 20-game minimum.

Now if a top player retires I could see it being a bit different. Maybe they change it to 20 points per year until they fall out of the top 100 or wherever you cut it off. But this would prevent craziness like what Kasparov is joking about, or even the current situation where Topalov and Anand are way overrated because they barely play but could still get invites based on their ranking.
Agreed. There should be some sort of ratings decay for inactivity. Say.. 1 point a month, but only applied every half year
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarthFed
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
DarthFed Other Sports 262
Federberg Other Sports 46
DarthFed Other Sports 150