Sorry, I thought it was clear...I disagree that he wants it both ways. I thought you were the guy who doesn't think every person has to pull in with one side or the other completely. There is no Democratic platform on PC-ness, so why can't Maher be essentially with the Democrats and call out PC BS when he sees it? I don't see that as "having it both ways," by any means.
Because his core convictions lead to the PC BS, that's why. Even in that video I posted, he says something to the effect that the black people he knows want acknowledgement of the horrors of past racism, but they don't want white people to totally degrade themselves either. The problem is that is exactly what murat is talking about - having it both ways.
This is what Maher wants people to say:
"Slavery and segregation were horrible and unimaginably terrible things. But we can all be cool now as long as we support the Democratic Party's agenda of the moment, regardless of how much it may shift year to year or decade to decade. Just support the party and then we can make some un-PC jokes to each other to be authentic and have a good time. He-he I'm Bill Maher and I'm real."
For Bill Maher (and for you Moxie), the Democratic Party is a church. It has your unwavering loyalty and it is your moral compass on social issues. Whatever the flavor of the day is for the Democratic Party, both you and Maher will support it, whether it is gay marriage or defending "trans" people from critics.
Now the problem with Maher's racial logic on both slavery and segregation is that is based on a ridiculously distorted view of human history in general. Slavery may have been an unjust and unpleasant institution, but the harsh reality is that it was practiced by people of all races for millennia. Singling out whites enslaving blacks for a couple centuries in North America would be like taking a group of 50 prostitutes and accusing one of being more whorish than the rest. As for segregation, it was socially degrading but it certainly was not on the level of murder, torture, war, POW exploitation, or genocide, which is how people talk about it today. On that note, from 1939 to 1945, what would any rational person have preferred of these two options?
1) Being a white European during the most fatal war in human history in which the regimes of genocidal murderers and war criminals were killing millions of people on the European continent, or
2) Being a black person in the American South who does not have the curse (I mean privilege) of sitting at the same hot dog counter as Moxie and Riotbeard to hear their inane comments about the world?
Option 2 is clearly preferable.